Chicago-style and Detroit-style pizzas are both iconic regional pizza styles in the United States, but they differ significantly in terms of preparation, presentation, and taste. Here are the key differences between the two:
1. Shape and Pan
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Shape: Chicago-style pizza, particularly the deep-dish variant, is round and resembles a pie.
- Pan: It is baked in a round, deep, and often buttered pan. The deep dish gives it a pie-like appearance with high, thick crust edges.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Shape: Detroit-style pizza is rectangular.
- Pan: It is baked in a rectangular, blue steel pan originally designed for automotive use, giving the pizza its distinct shape and crispy, caramelized edges.
2. Crust
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Crust: The crust is thick, buttery, and more like a pie crust. It has a slightly flaky texture due to the use of oil or butter in the dough.
- Texture: The crust is dense and rich, providing a sturdy base for the heavy toppings.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Crust: The crust is thick but airy and soft on the inside, with a crispy, caramelized exterior, especially around the edges where the cheese melts against the pan.
- Texture: It’s lighter and more bread-like compared to the dense Chicago crust, with a focus on crispiness at the edges.
3. Cheese
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Cheese: Chicago-style deep-dish pizza often uses mozzarella cheese, which is placed directly on the dough, beneath the toppings and sauce.
- Application: The cheese forms a gooey layer that is the first ingredient laid down, preventing the crust from becoming soggy under the heavy sauce and toppings.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Cheese: Traditionally uses Wisconsin brick cheese, which is spread all the way to the edges of the pan.
- Application: The cheese in Detroit-style pizza melts and caramelizes against the pan, creating a crispy, cheesy edge that is one of the pizza’s defining features.
4. Sauce Placement
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Sauce Placement: In a classic deep-dish, the sauce is ladled on top of the cheese and toppings, creating a thick, chunky layer of tomato sauce on the surface.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Sauce Placement: The sauce is often applied in two thick stripes over the cheese and toppings, though some variations spread the sauce evenly. This method is called “sauce on top,” and it keeps the crust light and airy.
5. Toppings
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Toppings: Chicago-style pizzas are known for being heavy on toppings, with a thick layer of cheese, meats like sausage or pepperoni, vegetables, and then a generous layer of tomato sauce on top. It’s a very hearty pizza.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Toppings: Toppings are placed directly on the dough before the cheese and sauce. While Detroit-style pizzas can have a variety of toppings, they’re often less dense than those on a Chicago-style pizza. Pepperoni is a common topping, placed beneath the cheese to create a crispy, flavorful layer.
6. Overall Presentation and Experience
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Experience: Eating a Chicago deep-dish pizza is like eating a savory pie. It’s very filling, and a single slice can be a meal in itself due to its thickness and richness. The sauce on top gives it a distinct appearance and makes it a very saucy pizza.
- Fork and Knife: It’s often eaten with a fork and knife due to its thickness.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Experience: Detroit-style pizza is less about being thick and filling, and more about the contrast between the light, airy interior and the crispy, cheesy exterior. The crispy edges are a unique and sought-after feature.
- Handheld: It’s typically cut into squares and can be eaten by hand, though the larger slices may still require a fork and knife.
7. Popularity and Availability
- Chicago-Style Pizza:
- Popularity: Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is famous nationwide and is often associated with the city itself. It has a strong presence in pizzerias both within Chicago and across the United States.
- Detroit-Style Pizza:
- Popularity: Detroit-style pizza has gained significant popularity in recent years, expanding beyond Detroit and becoming available in various regions across the U.S. Its rise in popularity is more recent compared to Chicago-style pizza.
Conclusion
While both Chicago-style and Detroit-style pizzas are deep-dish in nature, they offer vastly different experiences. Chicago-style is all about the thick, pie-like experience with a buttery crust and a rich layer of toppings and sauce. Detroit-style, on the other hand, emphasizes a balance between a light, airy crust and crispy, cheesy edges, with its unique sauce-on-top approach. Each style has its own devoted following and is a reflection of the culinary traditions of its respective city.
Photo by Jonathan J. Castellon on Unsplash